| 2005 | Peter Hill | Pittsford Mendon | ||
| 2004 | Brian Usinger | Penfield | Chris Farnsworth | Spencerport |
| 2003 | Adam Blanchard | Greece Arcadia | Keith Manscuk | Aquinas |
| 2002 | Eric Ducey | Pittsford Mendon | ||
| 2001 | Josh Bolton | Penfield | Jordon Chirico | Livonia |
|
1998 |
Guido Christofori |
(Fairport) |
||
| 1997 |
Jeff Parinnello |
(Mendon) |
||
| 1996 |
Jeff Parinnello |
Mendon |
Adam Gill | Bath-Haverling |
| 1995 |
Dimitri Kovalenko |
Arcadia |
Alex Korol | Livonia |
| 1994 |
Mike Cellura |
Penfield |
Dimo Kovalenko | Arcadia |
| 1993 |
Mike Domm |
Brighton |
||
| 1992 |
Dana Quick |
Spencerport |
||
| 1991 | Dana Quick |
Spencerport |
||
| 1990 |
Dana Quick |
Spencerport |
Peter Spear | Sutherland |
| 1989 | Jack Elliot | Penfield | Flemming Koeller | Mendon |
| 1988 |
Mike Campisi |
Aquinas | Tyler Ricks | Mendon |
| 1987 |
Mike Bianchi |
Arcadia |
Rhett Thompson | Sutherland |
| 1986 |
Mark Fish |
Fairport | Chris Kennel | Mendon |
| 1985 |
John Escalante |
Brockport | Carl Hopfinger | Sutherland |
| 1984 |
Jim Clar |
Gates Chili | Joe Sternberg | Sutherland |
| 1983 |
Chuck Burpee |
Arcadia |
||
| 1982 |
Jim Gallina |
Webster Thomas | ||
| 1981 |
John Pietek |
Arcadia | ||
| 1980 | Peter Grillo | Marshall | ||
| 1979 |
Chris Castano |
Mendon |
Steve Tremaine |
Olympia |
| 1978 |
Peter Buisman |
Penfield |
Jim Gentile | Spencerport |
| 1977 | Bill Champaigne | Mendon | ||
| 1976 | Rich Benson | Spencerport | Craig Jackson | Webster |
| 1975 | Scott Boddery | Webster | Bob Brooks | Spencerport |
| Rick Kincade | Spencerport | |||
| 1974 | Jim Berardicurti | Spencerport | ||
| 1973 | Win Jacop | Olympia | ||
| 1972 | Gary Boughter | Spencerport | Skip Small | Churchville |
| 1971 | Hal Dreschler | Olympia | ||
| 1970 | Dave Sarachan | Brighton | Kevin Hill | Wayne |
| Terry Lipman | Brighton | |||
| 1969 | Tom Gentile | Wayne | ||
| PARADE | MAGAZINE | ALL-AMERICA | ||
| 1992 | Dana Quick | |||
| 1979 | Ken Hayward | |||